I am maintaining this list actively.

I work day to day in software engineering where all everyone talks about is AI and it's impact.

Biases

I am anti-AI when it comes to creative arts, music, entertainment etc.

I am generally middle of the road when it comes to AI use for productivity.

I read AI research papers, test out AI tools, and experiment with coding agents at work to give myself the opportunity of a fair assessment.

Things AI Agents are contributing to software engineering:

  • Generating trivial and tedious code.
  • Greatly improving intellisense.
  • Maintaining dependencies.
  • Maintaining and configuring CI pipelines, automation and bash scripts etc.
  • Providing decent human-readable insights into stacktraces that then help me figure out a bug quicker. (Note - not actually fixing the bug itself or figuring it out).
  • Saving ~10% of the time it took me to write some non-trivial code by offering me suggestions on what I might want to type next.
  • Saving ~30% of my time doing some refactoring.
  • Shortcutting documentation and note taking, particularly with incidents.

Things AI Agents are not solving for software engineering:

  • Working well with technical people.
  • Working well with non-technical people.
  • The inertia of big organisations.
  • Co-ordinating and prioritising roadmaps.
  • Making the hard decisions of what we work on now versus what we drop.
  • Discovering the most valuable solution to a user's problem.
  • Discovering the most pragmatic solution to a user's problem.
  • Figuring out what "pragmatic solution" means within the context of the tech stack, code, problem space, stakeholder appetite and timelines.
  • Innovative and novel approaches to existing solutions.
  • Teaching a stakeholder to talk about their problem and not the solution they want.
  • Pairing back a fully featured product to it's thinest slice of value.
  • Managing the healthy tension between releasing today to create a small amount of value, and releasing next week with a more fully featured product.
  • The "shower thinking" and "programmer's dream" divine inspiration.
  • The knowledge you have built about the domain you work in.
  • Knowing the "gotchas" that aren't described in code, or documented, but are inherent behavioural issues that occur when a new feature is introduced or novel interactions are seen.

Things AI is doing

  • Providing some productivity boosts in the programming portion of a software engineer's job.
  • Distracting decision makers from identical value produced through cheaper, quicker, more deterministic, less carbon-intensive means.
  • Making a lot of decision makers solution's tool first, not problem first.

Things AI is not doing

  • Being the best technical solution to every user problem.
  • Replacing engineers.